> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.rebelnews.ie/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# No going back: Sinn Féin, Garvaghy and the dead end of Stormont
- URL: https://www.rebelnews.ie/no-going-back-sinn-fein-garvaghy-and-the-dead-end-of-stormont/
- Published: 2026-11-16T21:00:53.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-16T21:00:53.000Z
- Author: Rebekah Corbett

**Opinion polls show that Sinn Féin is riding high as it enters a season with elections due in May. However, behind their apparent success lies a strategic weakness. Here Rebekah Corbett examines how they are ‘boring from within’ the Stormont Assembly and critiques the results.**

Just a few months ago, Sinn Féin was wallowing at five-year polling lows. But they could hardly have scripted a better autumn.

The latest LucidTalk poll shows a record surge, with their lead over the SDLP having almost doubled since August from nine points to 17\. Unionism, meanwhile, has splintered three ways with a single point between the UUP, DUP and TUV. The DUP sits seven points below even its disastrous 2022 result.

The cause is no mystery. When the Orange Order tried to march down the Garvaghy Road, Sinn Féin stood with the residents to block it.

After a run of setbacks in government, the party reconnected with a grassroots base that had come to see it as institutionalised and detached. Its election slogan, ‘no going back’, will be plastered everywhere between now and May.

But step back from the polls and look at the institution Sinn Féin wants to lead. Seven months into the financial year, Stormont still hasn’t agreed a budget.

Departments are running on 95% of last year’s money – a punitive cut for public services in dire need of investment. Late-night bus and train services are up for the axe.

Health trusts are hunting further ‘efficiency savings’, including cutting specialist mental health support for young people in the North West on the weekends and bank holidays, and abolishing the ‘Phone First’ triage service in the Belfast Trust – just as winter pressures on our emergency departments begin to take hold. Further education colleges are planning to cut a whopping 8,000 places in the next academic year. Funding for apprenticeship programmes has been gutted.

The Executive parties, continually at war, are agreed on one thing: the extra £1.5 billion offered by the Secretary of State isn’t enough. Speculation is rife in political circles about when Stormont might collapse and who’s most likely to benefit from it.

But if you chat to anyone at the school gates or in a GP waiting room about whether they even care if Stormont collapses, most will simply shrug. Since 1998, it has sat for barely 60 per cent of the time. The better questions are who it was built for and how socialists should relate to it.

## Boring from within

There’s an old phrase on the left: boring from within. For Sinn Féin, since 1998 this strategy has involved a transition away from armed struggle and towards an institutional and electoral route towards its goals.

They have taken up ministries, tried to prove that they can govern and ostensibly treated the post-Good Friday Agreement institutions as stepping stones to a united Ireland. Sinn Féin has thrown its lot behind Stormont. Its best activists became special advisers and community workers and its street politics was wound down.

But nearly three decades on, it’s fair to say that the state has changed Sinn Féin far more than Sinn Féin has changed the state. Equality no longer means the redistribution of wealth. Inside Stormont – and local councils – it has come to mean parity between the two nationalist and unionist blocs, with each side getting its share of an ever-shrinking pot.

Sinn Féin’s record in office is remarkably thin. They agreed welfare cuts in the Fresh Start deal of 2015, backed a cut in corporation tax and signed off austerity budget after austerity budget. Today, a Sinn Féin Finance Minister blames London for the missing budget, while Invest NI weighs up a £67 million subsidy for Ryanair as children sit in classrooms in their coats because schools can’t afford their energy bills.

Casement Park was meant to be a flagship project in the heart of Sinn Féin’s own west Belfast stronghold. For over a decade, it’s sat as an empty wasteland on the Andersonstown Road.

The Good Jobs Bill, meant to improve workers’ rights, has been scuppered by the DUP. When Sinn Féin’s Infrastructure Minister, Liz Kimmins, moved to include Irish alongside English on signage at the newly-constructed Belfast Grand Central station, Jamie Bryson threatened a legal challenge and design work was halted. The Executive still hasn’t delivered the Irish language strategy that was promised in 1998.

Sinn Féin’s response to these obstructions to their political agenda has been anaemic. But this is no accident.

The sectarian carve-up of Stormont guarantees the two biggest parties – Sinn Féin and the DUP – the top two jobs, control of Assembly business and a veto over anything they don’t like. Sinn Féin benefits from this arrangement every bit as much as the DUP. This is why the party that talks so frequently about equality has done least to dismantle designations and the petition of concern – the very mechanisms used to block it.

Meanwhile, it has worked hard at respectability. A First Minister ‘for all’ sat through the coronation of a king.

Senior figures, north and south, reassure multinationals and business lobbies that Sinn Féin is no threat to them. Ultimately, they want to be seen as a safe pair of hands by the people who own this island.

Marx drew the lesson from the Paris Commune: the working class “cannot simply lay hold of the ready-made state machinery, and wield it for its own purposes.” Stormont is no exception. Spend your time administering an unjust settlement and it ends up shaping you. This is the inevitable logic of Sinn Féin’s strategy.

If that strategy was *ever* going to work, it should have served them well earlier this year. Michelle O’Neill has become the First Minister and Stormont was up and running.

Yet a court ruling and a Parades Commission decision inexplicably put an Orange march back on the Garvaghy Road. The Executive, the Irish government and all the post-Agreement North-South bodies were powerless to stop it.

Michelle O’Neill ended up on the Garvaghy Road alongside thousands of people who oppose the reactionary, triumphalist politics of the Orange Order. Sinn Féin reps were obviously entirely correct to be there, but it showed the limits of their approach. It’s telling that after thirty years of unquestioning faith in the institutions, Sinn Féin had to fall back on the oldest tool there is: people power.

Yet the lesson the party has drawn is the opposite one. It is throwing its lot behind Stormont once again. MPs Pat Cullen, Paul Maskey, Chris Hazzard and Órfhlaith Begley are being run in Assembly constituencies for May’s election, and Gerry Kelly has reversed his decision to retire.

At first glance, that looks like a show of strength – a party confident enough to chase new seats. But it’s arguably a defensive move.

Sinn Féin has no shortage of councillors and activists who could stand. Instead it is effectively demoting its MPs, because it needs its biggest names to maximise its gains. It is doubling down on the strategy that has demonstrably failed it for 30 years.

## Unionism’s dead end

Unionism is in a historic crisis. It lost its Assembly majority in 2017, in a state whose border was drawn to guarantee one.

It has lost its material base too: the shipyard, the engineering works and the mills that once bound working-class Protestants into a cross-class alliance. What replaced them was RHI, Red Sky and NAMA – public money for the friends of the unionist elite, while those on the Shankill are doomed to deprivation and neglect.

With nothing to offer, the DUP has made obstruction a strategy and culture war a substitute for politics. Drumcree was meant to rouse its base, but that base decided to stay at home.

Now the party is squeezed by the TUV and the UUP, and Carla Lockhart’s resignation has exposed its split over collapsing Stormont. There is talk of Gavin Robinson pulling the plug once a budget is agreed.

This is sure to be another Arlene Foster ‘crocodiles’ moment for Sinn Féin. In 2017, Foster’s sectarian sneer at Irish language campaigners drove up nationalist turnout and left Sinn Féin a single seat behind the DUP. The DUP collapsing the Executive now would remove Michelle O’Neill as First Minister and hand Sinn Féin another huge boost.

## Built to divide

None of this is an accident. The Good Friday Agreement helped end the bloodshed of the Troubles, and 71% of people voted for it for good reason.

But peace was pushed from below – by workers who walked out in protest against sectarian murders and trade unionists who refused to be divided. The space that was opened was filled by the sectarian parties, who cut a deal at the top while communities stayed divided. There are more peace walls today than in 1998, and nine in ten children still go to schools separated by religion.

The Agreement assumes sectarianism is a permanent fixture to be managed, rather than a poison to be eradicated. James Connolly warned that partition would bring “a carnival of reaction both North and South”, and we’ve seen this farce play out repeatedly in northern politics.

And when Stormont does work, we only have to look at who it works for. Multinationals like Moy Park, Coca Cola and Caterpillar benefit from an antiquated rates relief policy that exists nowhere else on these islands, while local charities and community groups lose their funding and workers are constantly put on protective notice. The agri-food giants poisoning Lough Neagh go almost entirely unchallenged.

## What replaces Stormont?

Socialists must fight for any democratic reform that loosens the sectarian grip: including one MLA, one vote; the scrapping of the petition of concern and minority protections written into an enforceable Bill of Rights; voluntary coalition, rather than mandatory coalition. But reform should always be a means, rather than the destination. Sectarian division is baked into Stormont and, in many ways, it is irreformable.

We don’t simply want a tidier Stormont, and we don’t want the North simply folded into a Southern state of landlords and vulture funds. When a border poll comes, we must argue for an Ireland built from the bottom up: community assemblies with real budgets and power over housing and planning; workers with a direct say in how public services are run; representatives on a worker’s wage, recallable the moment they stop listening.

In that Ireland, housing, land, energy and the banks would belong to all of us, run democratically rather than for profit. Healthcare would be a single all-Ireland service, free at the point of use. The church would finally be prised out of our schools and hospitals for good.

This might sound utopian to some, but we’ve seen glimpses of this possible future in our very recent past; Garvaghy Road residents defending their own street, neighbours protecting migrant families from racist mobs each of the past three summers, 150,000 workers shutting down public services together to win fair pay in January 2024\. Every time working class people organise together, they show they can run things better than the people in Parliament Buildings.

*Rebekah Corbett works as a parliamentary assistant in Stormont.*